Title ownership dispute resolution

We allow members to freely register DOI records for titles that do not yet exist in our system. Term 2d of our membership terms states:

Rights to Content. The Member will not deposit or register Metadata for any Content for which the Member does not have legal rights to do so.

This means that either the journal owner or their appointed publisher can register DOI records for a title.

When the first record submission related to a new title is processed, a title record is created in our database. This title record ties the title to the prefix belonging to the first registrant, and this member becomes the “owning member”. From this point, new DOIs for content in that specific title can only be created on the owning member prefix. If another member wishes to register DOIs for content belonging to that title, they can’t do this unless we move ownership of the title in our system to them. Only one member can be the owning member for a title at any given time.

Title ownership transfers in our system are really common and usually straightforward, and we follow our standard title ownership transfer process. But very occasionally there’s a disagreement between two members about who should be registering DOIs for a specific title, and the member who wants to take ownership of the title in our system becomes the “disputing member”. In these very rare cases, we follow this process:

  • The disputing member will notify us of the title ownership dispute - an email to Support is sufficient
  • If the owning member has already had their membership revoked for a pattern of registering records in titles that don’t belong to them, or other behaviour in contravention of our member terms and practices, we may transfer ownership of the title to the disputing member. Our Director of Membership will review the available external evidence that the disputing member is the owner or appointed publisher of the title and make a decision based on the evidence. If there is not compelling evidence, title ownership will not be transferred to the disputing member.
  • In all other cases, we’ll contact the owning member, informing them of the title ownership dispute.
    • If the owning member agrees that their ownership is incorrect or if they do not respond within 10 working days, we will reassign title and record ownership to the disputing member, who then becomes the new owning member.
    • If the owning member challenges the claim, the two parties must resolve the issue together. We will only transfer title ownership in our system at the owning member’s direction, or at the direction of legal authority. If the dispute is not resolved within 90 days, the disputing member can request that we remove any party’s ability to register further records for the title under dispute until this is resolved. This remains the case until we receive transfer notification from the owning member, or notice of a legal conclusion.

Page maintainer: Amanda Bartell
Last updated: 2026-September-23